CLAT Logical Reasoning Practice Questions 2

Directions: read the following passage and answer the questions that follow

Since 2000, the National Crime Record Bureau (NCRB) has been publishing annual data on deaths in Indian jails, providing insight into the circumstances surrounding these incidents. Categorized as "natural" and "unnatural" deaths, approximately 1,800 individuals have been dying in Indian prisons each year for over two decades. However, in 2021, the number of prisoner deaths rose significantly to 2,116, prompting the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) to issue a 21-page advisory on managing prison deaths, particularly those resulting from suicide.

The advisory, released on June 19, focuses on mitigating self-harm and suicide attempts by prisoners. Recognizing that prison suicides are influenced by medical and mental health issues, the NHRC emphasizes the need to increase prison staff and provide adequate training. It also recommends screening incarcerated individuals upon entry, closely monitoring high-risk prisoners, and establishing a collaborative framework to address suicide prevention in prisons.

Despite issuing a similar advisory in 2014, the NHRC acknowledges that the number of deaths has not decreased over the past decade. Consequently, the commission has issued a more comprehensive guideline this time, emphasizing the need to fill vacancies and augment staff strength in Indian prisons.

India's prisons suffer from severe staff shortages, with vacant positions remaining unfilled year after year. The number of sanctioned positions does not account for the problem of overcrowding, which has reached alarming levels in some prisons, exceeding 500%. Specifically, there is a shortage of medical officers, with only a fraction of the required positions filled. As a result, one medical officer is responsible for the health concerns of a significantly high number of prisoners.

Moreover, the distribution of hospital staff is uneven, with states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh having the highest number of vacancies. In the absence of sufficient medical officers, prisoners are often transported to external hospitals. Due to the lack of independent inquiries, deaths in prisons are frequently labeled as "natural," despite potential foul play or suspicious circumstances.

In addition, the NHRC's efforts to address deaths in custody have been hindered by non-compliance with mandatory judicial magisterial inquiries. While the NHRC requires timely intimation of deaths in custody and relevant reports, it has faced challenges in accessing these details, even under the Right to Information Act. The data also highlights the prevalence of mental illnesses among prisoners, but inadequate mental health practitioners hinder early diagnosis and intervention. The NHRC's advisory recommends involving medical staff in screening prisoners and suggests increased surveillance measures, such as CCTVs, to address suicidal ideation. However, an excessive focus on surveillance in a hierarchical system may lead to further human rights violations.

In summary, the NCRB's annual data sheds light on deaths in Indian jails, and the alarming rise in prisoner deaths has spurred the NHRC to issue an advisory emphasizing the need for preventive measures, increased staff strength, and better mental health support. However, systemic challenges, including staff shortages and lack of accountability, continue to pose significant hurdles in addressing the complex issues surrounding deaths in prisons.

1. 
Based on the information provided in the passage, which of the following statements cannot be inferred?

2. 
What is the central idea of the passage regarding the measures taken to address deaths in Indian jails and improve prison conditions?

3. 
What assumption is required for the conclusion that the shortage of medical staff in prisons has contributed to the increase in deaths?

4. 
"India’s prisons have for long been plagued by acute shortages of staff and the vacant positions go unfilled year after year." Which of the following statements, if true, would weaken the argument that the shortage of staff in Indian prisons is a persistent problem?

5. 
"The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has issued advisories to address the issue of deaths in Indian jails, particularly suicides. However, despite the issuance of these advisories, the number of deaths has not decreased over the past decade and has, in fact, shown a drastic increase." How can this paradox be resolved? Which of the following options best resolves the paradox stated above?

DU LLB : A Complete Guide to 3 & 5 Year Law Programs

Delhi University (DU) is one of the most prestigious institutions in India, known for its quality education and vibrant campus life. For aspiring lawyers, DU offers two popular law pathways: ✅ 3-Year LLB (Post-Graduation in Law)✅ 5-Year Integrated BA LL.B...

How DU CSAS Works : Guide to Delhi University Admissions 2025

What is DU CSAS? DU’s Common Seat Allocation System (CSAS‑UG) is the digital platform where aspirants for undergraduate admission apply, list their preferred courses and colleges, and receive seat allocations based on their CUET‑UG scores, reservation categories, and...

B.com vs B. com ( Hons.)? Which is Better for You ?

After Class 12, most commerce students face a common confusion – Should I choose B.Com (General) or B.Com (Honours)? Both are undergraduate commerce courses, but they differ in depth, career opportunities, and specialization. Let’s understand what they are, their...

Hotel Management Course & Career Opportunities

The Hotel Management course is ideal for students who wish to build a career in the hospitality, tourism, and service industry. It covers hotel operations, culinary arts, housekeeping, front office management, and event planning.  ✅ Eligibility Qualification:...

BJMC: Details, Eligibility, Fees, Syllabus & Career Scope

Are you passionate about storytelling, news, social media, or the world of digital content? Then a BJMC (Bachelor of Journalism and Mass Communication) could be your gateway to an exciting career in media and communication. In this blog, we’ll cover everything you...

BCA : Course, Career Opportunities & jobs

If you’re passionate about technology, coding, and IT careers, the Bachelor of Computer Applications (BCA) is one of the best undergraduate degrees you can choose. In this guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know about BCA – course details, specializations,...

BBA: Specializations, Entrance Exam , Career & Scope

If you’re passionate about business, management, and leadership, the Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA) could be your gateway to a rewarding career. It’s one of the most popular undergraduate programs for students who aspire to build a strong foundation in...

Career Leaders : Best CLAT Coaching Institute for 2026

Cracking CLAT 2026 and getting into a top National Law University needs the right strategy, the best mentors, and proper guidance. That’s exactly what Career Leaders delivers. Here are 5 strong reasons why Career Leaders is the best CLAT coaching for you.✅ 1....

CLAT EXAM 2026 : Complete Guide to India’s Top Law Exam

If you dream of studying law at one of India’s premier National Law Universities (NLUs), the CLAT (Common Law Admission Test) is your gateway. It’s one of the most competitive entrance exams for aspiring lawyers and opens doors to top-notch legal education and career...

Why LLB ? The Benefits of a LAW Degree Beyond Courtrooms

When people hear the word lawyer, they often imagine someone arguing passionately in a courtroom. But pursuing an LLB—Bachelor of Laws—is about much more than becoming a courtroom advocate. It’s a degree that sharpens your mind, opens doors to countless career...

CLAT Logical Reasoning Practice Questions 2

Career Leaders is the best result oriented institute for sure shot results in all entrance exams after class 12th.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *